Evidence on A.I. Exposure, Earnings, and Workforce Pell

Technological change is reshaping work. Education is changing with it.

Opportunity has always depended on education. As artificial intelligence transforms the economy, it is reshaping the knowledge, skills, and credentials that create economic opportunity.

Opportunity Data is an independent research platform built on public data. We develop statistical infrastructure, decision-support frameworks, and transparent analysis that help researchers, policymakers, institutions, employers, and learners understand how technological change is reshaping education, work, and opportunity.

Building open infrastructure from public data.

Explore the data infrastructure
1,806
academic programs scored for A.I. exposure
1,100+
institutions in the graduate earnings data
52
jurisdictions on the State Implementation Record
Used, cited, or linked by
NPR American Association of Community Colleges Child Trends UPCEA Higher Learning Commission Indiana Department of Workforce Development Washington Monthly Chalkbeat New America

Why Opportunity Data Exists

The labor market is changing faster than the systems built to measure it. Administrative records, education data, and emerging A.I. indicators already contain signals about how opportunity is being reshaped, but those signals sit in separate systems designed for compliance, reporting, and institutional use, not for public understanding.

Opportunity Data turns those public resources into indexes, crosswalks, state-by-state implementation records, and interactive explorers that anyone can use and reuse. Rather than producing one-time reports, we build open infrastructure from public data. Opportunity Data is not tied to a vendor, membership organization, or predetermined implementation model.

Data Infrastructure

Four interactive components, each grounded in public data sources and reproducible end-to-end.

AI & Labor Market Disruption

AI Exposure Index

Which occupations are most exposed to A.I. automation, and which academic programs feed into them? Three-dimensional scoring across digital intensity, human interaction, and physical work. 696 occupations, 1,806 programs.

Explore the Index
Detailed tables: By Academic Program (CIP) · By Occupation (SOC)
How the index compares with the BLS AI Exposure Categories
AI Exposure · By State

AI Exposure of Academic Programs by State

How A.I.-exposed is each state's mix of graduates? A completion-weighted map of all 50 states and D.C., built from 5.3 million IPEDS 2023 completions and the A.I. Exposure Index, with credential breakdowns and a findings brief.

Explore the State Map Findings Brief (PDF)
Current Flagship · Effective July 1, 2026

Workforce Pell Implementation

From eligibility screening to state implementation. Approximate the federal earnings test program by program, track each governor's progress in standing up the approval pipeline, and compare the occupation lists states are approving.

Value-Added Earnings Test State Implementation Record State Approval Comparison
Program Earnings

Postsecondary Earnings Data

What graduates actually earn at 1, 5, and 10 years, drawn from Census Bureau administrative wage records. Trajectories, within-program variation, and where suppression limits what we can see. 1,100+ institutions in 37 states and DC, three credential levels.

Explore Earnings Data
By Field of Study

Recent Graduate Outcomes

How 73 bachelor's fields compare on underemployment, unemployment, early-career pay, and the number of graduates, mapped together so you can see both the odds and the scale. New York Fed outcomes paired with IPEDS completion counts.

By Field (Snapshot) BETA Underemployment Over Time BETA AI Exposure and the Earnings Record New
Census PSEO BLS OES O*NET IPEDS College Scorecard NY Fed

Data products built on the same infrastructure

The datasets behind every component are free to download with a citation. Paid products add what the free layer does not hold: back editions of the State Implementation Record, state-level nuclear workforce reports, and a program portfolio review for one college. Custom research and state reviews are quoted through Work With Us.

See all data products

Research that builds open infrastructure

Every article, dataset, and visualization contributes to a larger body of open statistical infrastructure for understanding education, work, and opportunity. Interactive analyses paired with published op-eds in national and trade press.

Author Analysis

The Earnings Record Cannot See the AI Shock Yet

October 2026 · Analysis

Unemployment among new graduates in the most AI-exposed tenth of majors nearly doubled between 2022 and 2024, computer science enrollment fell by an eighth this fall, and the federal earnings test cannot score a cohort that graduated after ChatGPT before 2029. Public survey, Census, and Clearinghouse data read through the Opportunity Data AI Exposure Index and the rule text.

View analysis →
Author Analysis

Where Short-Term Credentials Lead, State by State

July 2026 · Interactive

Every state's certificate portfolio measured against two facts the federal Workforce Pell test collapses into one: whether a field's completers clear the national median wage, and whether their earnings keep climbing. A map, all 51 portfolios, and the four buckets that divide 1.02 million certificates.

View analysis →
Author Analysis

The Teacher Credential Ladder

June 2026 · Interactive

Where the teacher-preparation ladder steps up. PSEO earnings for graduates of CIPs 13.10 (Special Ed), 13.12 (Subject Area/Secondary), and 13.13 (Levels & Methods/Elementary) at the associate's and bachelor's levels, paired with NY Fed underemployment and BLS K-12 teacher wages.

View analysis →
Author Analysis

The Childcare Credential Ladder

April 2026 · Interactive

Below the bachelor's, the child development credential ladder is flat: a certificate and an associate's earn the same. PSEO earnings for Human Development and Family Studies graduates, paired with BLS OEWS wages and MIT Living Wage data across states.

View analysis →
State Analysis · Colorado

Colorado's Childcare Credential Ladder

May 2026 · Interactive

Colorado-only cut of the national ladder. PSEO earnings for graduates of 16 Colorado colleges in Human Development and Family Studies, paired with the Colorado Department of Early Childhood's published lead-teacher vs. kindergarten-teacher wage comparison and Child Care Aware of America's 2024 Colorado prices.

View analysis →

In the press

Opportunity Data research and commentary has been published in The Colorado Sun, Washington Monthly, and Community College Daily, published by the American Association of Community Colleges.

Methodology

How the data infrastructure works. Data sources, formulas, scoring, and the limits of what the data can show. Neutral documentation, not commentary.

Technical Note

AI Exposure Index Methodology

April 2026

How the AI Exposure Index is constructed: variable selection from O*NET, dimension scoring for digital intensity, human interaction shield, and physical anchor, and the crosswalk from occupations to academic programs.

Read methodology →
Technical Note

The Limits of PSEO

2026

What the Post-Secondary Employment Outcomes data can and can't tell us about program value. UI coverage gaps, small-cell suppression, and non-random missingness, layered out.

Read methodology →

Get in touch

Released March 2026 · Updated November 2026