What actually happens  /  Analysis

Of 100 students who start at a public community or technical college, an estimated 40 to 44 earn a credential within eight years

Of every 100 students who entered a public community or technical college in 2017-18, 32 earned a certificate or degree there within eight years. Another 27 transferred to another college without one, and an estimated 8 to 13 of them earned a credential at a later college, bringing the total to about 40 to 44 of 100 (parts are rounded separately). 40 left, and the college has no record of them enrolling anywhere else. An estimated 21 of the 100 completed where they started and, a year later, earned more than the national median for high school graduates aged 25 to 34 ($35,678). At public universities the estimate is 46 of 100. Universities enroll more full-time students, and their cohorts include students who transferred in from community colleges, so the gap does not show which sector does better for the same student.

This analysis estimates each step from enrollment to earnings for each state and sector: completion, transfer, work, earnings above a high school benchmark, jobs below the credential's level, and tuition. The sources are IPEDS Outcome Measures (the federal completion survey that includes part-time students and students who transfer in), College Scorecard earnings from federal tax records, and the American Community Survey.

Key findings

United States, students who entered in 2017-18

  1. 40 to 44
    Of 100 community and technical college starters earn a credential within eight years
    32 where they started (all entering students); an estimated 8 to 13 after transferring, from federal aid records (the higher figure counts credentials at any college and may be overstated; the lower counts only four-year colleges); parts are rounded separately
  2. 21 of 100
    Finish where they started and out-earn a high school graduate a year later
    Estimate; benchmark is the national median for high school graduates aged 25 to 34 ($35,678)
  3. $6,085
    Associate's graduates' first-year earnings premium over high school
    Median first-year earnings of graduates who work, minus the national median for high school graduates aged 25 to 34 ($35,678)
  4. 60%
    Of employed associate's holders aged 22 to 27 who are not in school, the share in occupations that typically require a high school diploma or less
    BLS typical entry education by occupation; not a measure of skills used on the job
01

Findings

Our assessment

Most starters who do not reach the earnings benchmark leave before completing.

Few starters complete and then have no earnings a year out: an estimated 2 of 100 community and technical college starters (about 6 percent of their completers) and 3 of 100 at public universities. Most of the gap comes earlier: 40 of 100 community and technical college starters leave without a credential, and the starting college has no record of them enrolling elsewhere (some did enroll elsewhere without the college learning of it). Federal student aid records for an earlier cohort of aid recipients (2015-16 entrants) count 39 percent who withdrew with no later enrollment record at any college, a similar share. Transfer is a partial route to a credential: of the 27 who transfer before earning one, an estimated 8 to 13 earn one at a later college within eight years, and about 11 leave. Most of the difference between states also comes from completion at the starting college, which is lower where more students transfer. Across the 44 states with enough data, completion accounts for about 66 percent of the state-to-state differences in the number of community and technical college starters who finish and out-earn the national high school benchmark. Completers' work and earnings account for about 17 percent. The remaining 17 percent reflects states where both are high or both are low. This is an accounting split of the figure (see Methods), not an estimate of what would change outcomes. Among states where credential levels with published earnings account for at least 95 percent of awards, the number who finish and out-earn ranges from 16 of 100 in Texas and California to 45 in South Dakota; at public universities, from 34 in Arizona to 58 in Iowa. The count does not credit students who earn a credential after transferring; counting them, an estimated 41 and 39 of 100 community and technical college starters earn a credential within eight years in Texas and California, respectively.

Treasury records follow federal aid recipients who entered a community or technical college in 2013-14 or 2014-15, finishers and non-finishers together. Eight years after entry, 53 of every 100 who were not enrolled were working and out-earning a high school graduate, and 14 percent had no earnings. In the ACS, 14 percent of adults aged 25 to 34 with some college and no degree had no earnings in the past year, against 11 percent of associate's holders and 21 percent of high school graduates. These are descriptive figures for different people and do not show what enrolling causes students to earn.

02

Read this first

What these figures can and cannot show

  1. Estimates, not one tracked group. Each stage is a rate from a different federal source and cohort: completion for all students who entered in 2017-18, transfer outcomes for federal aid recipients who entered in 2015-16, earnings for aid recipients who completed in 2020-21 or 2021-22. The journey multiplies those rates, and its earnings stage describes federal aid recipients only.
  2. The earnings stage covers completers at the starting college only. Students who finish after transferring, and students who leave, are not in it, and their earnings are not counted against or for the starting college. The finish-and-out-earn count is therefore lower where more students transfer before earning a credential; read it with “Credential within 8 years, anywhere.”
  3. A demanding, early benchmark. Earnings one year after completing are compared with high school graduates aged 25 to 34, who are older and further into their careers. First-year premiums are typically lower than later ones. The share who out-earn uses the Scorecard's national median ($35,678) in every state; the premium uses each state's own median. In states where the high school median is below the national value, the share who out-earn is lower than a state comparison would give; where it is above, higher.
  4. Transfer completion is a range. The number who earn a credential after transferring comes from federal aid records that record first credentials less often than Outcome Measures, so the higher figure (13 of 100 at community and technical colleges) may be overstated. Counting only credentials earned at four-year colleges gives 8.
  5. “Left, no record elsewhere” is not the same as dropping out. It means the starting college has no record of the student enrolling at another college. Some of these students did enroll elsewhere without the college learning of it.
  6. Jobs below the credential uses one typical entry requirement per occupation from the Bureau of Labor Statistics. It does not observe what skills a worker uses, and the ACS cannot identify certificate holders.
  7. Description, not cause. Differences between states and sectors reflect who enrolls as well as what colleges do. No figure here estimates what a credential causes a student to earn.

Every definition, source, cohort, and threshold is in the methodology note (PDF) and the data dictionary.

03

Guidance

For students and families

Most students who start at a community or technical college do not finish there. Nationally, about 32 of every 100 earn a certificate or degree at the college where they started within eight years. An estimated 8 to 13 more earn one after moving to another college. About 40 leave with no record of enrolling anywhere else.

Graduate earnings figures usually describe only the graduates who found work. This page shows every step, so you can see how many starters become graduates who found work. An estimated 21 of 100 community and technical college starters finish where they started and, a year later, earn more than the national median for high school graduates aged 25 to 34 ($35,678). At public universities the estimate is 46 of 100; universities enroll different students, including many who transferred in from community colleges, so the two figures are not your odds at one kind of college against the other.

These are averages for large groups of students. They are not your personal odds. Your own path depends on your program, your schedule, the support you get, and many other things. Use the figures as a starting point for questions to ask a college, not as a prediction.

Questions to ask a college before you enroll

  1. How many students who start here finish here, and how long does it take? Compare the answer with “Credential where they started” in the chart and in the All states table.
  2. If I plan to transfer, how many of your students who transfer go on to earn a credential? Compare with “Credential after transfer” in the chart and “% of transfers who finished elsewhere (est.)” in the By college drill-down.
  3. What share of students leave without finishing, and what help do you offer before they do? Compare with “Left, no record elsewhere” in the chart.
  4. What do graduates of this program earn a year after finishing, compared with high school graduates in this state? Compare with “Premium over high school” in the Earnings by credential table and the By field of study drill-down.
  5. How many graduates of this program have no earnings a year later? Compare with the “% of graduates with no earnings” column in the By field of study drill-down.
  6. What will I pay each year after grants, and how many years does the program usually take? Compare with “Tuition and fees per year” in the All states table (the published price, before grants) and the net price in the downloadable state table (after grants, including living costs).
  7. Do the jobs graduates get require this credential? Compare with the card on jobs below the credential, which shows how many young degree holders in your state work in jobs that usually need only a high school diploma.

How to read the chart

  1. Choose your state. The state picker changes every chart, table, and drill-down on the page. Then choose a type of college.
  2. Start on the left. The first column is 100 students who started at that type of college in 2017-18.
  3. Move right to eight years later. Each band shows how many of the 100 earned a credential where they started, transferred, were still enrolled, or left with no record of enrolling elsewhere.
  4. Keep going to the third column. Students who finished are split by the kind of credential they earned. Students who transferred are split by what happened next, including the estimated number who earned a credential at the next college.
  5. End on the right, one year after finishing. For students who finished where they started, the bands show how many earn more than the national median for high school graduates aged 25 to 34, how many work and earn that much or less, and how many have no earnings. Hover over or tap any band to see its count.

Words on this page

Credential
A certificate or degree a college awards when you finish a program.
Certificate
A credential from a shorter program, often one year or less, that trains you for a specific job.
Associate’s degree
A two-year degree, when taken full time, that can lead to a job or to transfer into a bachelor’s program.
Transfer
Moving from one college to another before earning a credential at the first one.
Left with no record elsewhere
The student did not earn a credential, and the starting college has no record of the student enrolling at another college.
Premium over high school
How much more the median graduate who works earns in the first year after finishing than the median high school graduate aged 25 to 34 in the same state (in the United States view, the national median). It describes graduates and does not show what the credential itself adds.
Median
The middle value: half of the group earns more and half earns less.
Tuition and net price
Tuition is the price a college publishes for classes and fees. Net price is what students pay on average after grants and scholarships (aid you do not pay back), including living costs.
“Of 100 starters”
Each figure is scaled to a group of 100 students who started at that type of college, so 21 of 100 means about 21 percent.
Estimate
A figure built by combining rates from several federal data sources about different groups of students, so it is approximate rather than an exact count.

What these numbers cannot tell you

Each figure on this page is an estimate built from federal data on different groups of students: completion for students who started in 2017-18, transfer results for students with federal aid who started in 2015-16, and earnings for students with federal aid who finished in 2020-21 or 2021-22. The numbers are averages for thousands of students, not your chances. Colleges enroll different students, such as more working adults, more part-time students, or more students who were well prepared for college, so a difference between two colleges or two states may reflect who enrolls as much as what the college does. Nothing here shows that earning a credential causes higher pay. Earnings are measured one year after finishing, early in a career, and are compared with high school graduates aged 25 to 34, who have had more years to work. Pay often changes in the years that follow.

04

Explorer

The journey, state by state

Pick a state and a sector. The chart estimates what happens to 100 students who entered in 2017-18, combining completion rates for that cohort with transfer and earnings rates for other cohorts of federal aid recipients. Hover over any band for its count.

Sets every chart, table, and drill-down on this page.
Figure 1What happens to 100 students who start in the United States

Scroll sideways to see the whole chart.

Download
The chart as shown, with its title and sources, for reuse with the credit “Source: Opportunity Data, opportunitydata.org.”

For this state and sector

Table 1

Earnings by credential

Completers at the college where they started, one year after completing. The premium is median earnings of those who work minus the median for high school graduates aged 25 to 34 in the state (the national median in the United States view); it describes graduates, not everyone who started, and is not a causal estimate.

Earnings by credential
CredentialPremium over high schoolMedian earnings% of working graduates above the national high school median% of graduates with no earningsOf 100 starters: earn it here and out-earn high school (est.)Tuition and fees, full program (1, 2, or 4 years)

Sources and notes for Figure 1 and Table 1. Completion, transfer, and departure: IPEDS Outcome Measures for students who entered in 2017-18, eight years after entry, all four entry groups (first-time and transfer-in, full-time and part-time). Credentials are split by the mix of certificates, associate's degrees, and bachelor's degrees the sector's colleges awarded. Work and earnings: College Scorecard counts for federal aid recipients who completed in 2020-21 and 2021-22, measured in calendar 2022 and 2023, in 2024 dollars, excluding completers still enrolled. A band labeled earnings not reported covers credentials whose programs are too small for Scorecard to publish counts. What happened to students who transferred comes from federal student aid records (NSLDS) for students who entered with federal aid in 2015-16, eight years after entry, applied to the Outcome Measures transfer share. The number who earn a credential after transferring is shown as a range: the low end counts only students who finished at a four-year college, and the high end, at which the flow is drawn, may be overstated. Students who finish after transferring have their earnings counted at the college where they finish, so they do not appear in this chart's earnings stage.

05

Fields and colleges

Drill down

Fields of study and individual colleges for the state and sector chosen above. These rows are each field's or college's own published figures; the stages are not multiplied together at this level.

Table 2

Drill-down

Download
Fields of study (CSV)Colleges (CSV)Definitions and caveats for both files are in the data dictionary.
06

Cost and payoff

Price, premium, and how many starters reach it

Each dot is a state. Position shows a credential's published tuition and fees and what its graduates earn above the state's high school benchmark. Size and color show an estimate of how many of every 100 students who start in the sector earn the credential at the starting college, work, and out-earn the national high school benchmark. A large premium on a small dot is a payoff few starters reach. The premium is a first-year figure for graduates who work; it is not an estimate of what the credential causes a student to earn.

Figure 2Tuition and fees against graduates' first-year premium, by stateWhen you choose a state, it is outlined in black. On small screens, tap a dot for its state.

Sources and notes. Tuition and fees: published in-state tuition and fees for 2025-26 (colleges that report a single program charge are not included), averaged across the sector's colleges by entering cohort and multiplied by the credential's nominal length (one year for a certificate, two for an associate's degree, four for a bachelor's). Most students take longer, and grants lower what many pay; net price (2024-25), which subtracts grants and adds living costs, is in the hover text and the download. Premium: median first-year earnings of working completers minus the median earnings of high school graduates aged 25 to 34 in the state. Dot size and color: of 100 students who start in the sector, the estimated number who earn this credential at the starting college and, a year later, out-earn the national median for high school graduates aged 25 to 34 ($35,678); students who earn it after transferring are not counted.

07

Reference table

All states

Most figures are per 100 students who entered the sector in the state in 2017-18. The exceptions are Entrants (a count), the eight-year column (per 100 federal aid recipients not enrolled, 2013-15 entrants), the premium, tuition, and the share of associate's holders aged 22 to 27 in high-school-level jobs. Click a column to sort.

Table 3

Outcome journey by state
Download
Download the state table (CSV)Every state and sector, with each credential's earnings, premium, tuition, net price, and starters reaching the premium, including rows too small to chart.Data dictionary and caveats (TXT)Definition, source, cohort, and limits of every column. Read it before using the figures.
08

Implications

What this means

What this means for Workforce Pell

The final Workforce Pell rule already judges short programs on most of this path. Under 34 CFR 690.94(a)(2) (91 FR 29254, 29336, May 19, 2026), a program must show a completion rate of at least 70 percent within 150 percent of normal time. It must also show a job placement rate of at least 70 percent in the second quarter after students leave. By default, from the 2029-30 award year, placement counts only employment in the occupation the program prepares students for, or a comparable high-skill, high-wage, or in-demand occupation. Published tuition and fees may not exceed the program's value-added earnings (34 CFR 690.95), a measure based on Pell completers' earnings adjusted for regional prices, net of 150 percent of the poverty line; that benchmark differs from the high school benchmark used here.

Graduate earnings alone leave out the two stages the federal rule tests first, completion and placement, and the occupational match it adds in 2029-30. A state reviewing Workforce Pell applications needs all three. The eight-year completion rates on this page cover programs of every length and every student, and they are not an estimate of any program's 150-percent completion rate under the rule. They describe the sector as a whole: 32 of 100 entering community and technical college students earn a credential at the college where they started within eight years.

Taxpayer perspective

Why it matters. Pell Grants are paid for each term a student enrolls, whether or not the student finishes. A graduate premium describes the students who finish and find work. The public cost also covers students who enroll and do not complete. Of 100 community and technical college starters, 40 leave without a credential, and the starting college has no record of them enrolling elsewhere.

What you can do. When a college or a ranking cites a graduate earnings premium, ask for the completion rate of students who started at that college and the share of its completers employed after they finish. IPEDS Outcome Measures publish completion for most colleges that award degrees; many certificate-only schools, including Tennessee's colleges of applied technology, do not report them. For Workforce Pell programs, institutions must give the Governor the list of completers and the information needed to verify job placement (34 CFR 690.94(b)(1)), and by default from 2029-30 placement counts only employment in the program's occupation or a comparable one (690.94(a)(2)(ii)(B)).

Appendix A

Robustness

Sensitivity checks

Sensitivity checks
CheckMain estimateAlternativeWhat it shows
Entry group, community and technical colleges32 of 100 earn a credential (all entrants)40 of 100 (first-time, full-time only); 22 (first-time, part-time)The common first-time, full-time rate describes only some of the students these colleges enroll, and it is higher than the rate for all entrants.
Students who transferred13 of 100 earn a credential after transferring (48% of transfers)8 of 100 counting only credentials earned at four-year collegesThe split comes from federal aid records, which record a credential at the starting college for 19 percent of community and technical college entrants against 32 percent in Outcome Measures. Students whose first credential went unrecorded appear there as transfers, so the share of transfers who finish may be overstated.
Branch-campus records20.77 of 100 out-earn (pooled records counted once)20.76 (every branch copy counted)Scorecard repeats earnings pooled at the parent institution on each branch; counting each record once changes the national figure by under one point.
Eight years after entry, earlier aid-recipient cohort21 of 100 finish and out-earn a year after completing53 of 100 aid recipients not enrolled work and out-earn eight years after entry (2013-15 entrants)A different cohort, population, and denominator (aid recipients not enrolled, against all entrants), measured later. The two are not directly comparable; the first-year completer figure is the lower of the two.
Jobs below the credential, associate's holders 22 to 2760% in occupations needing a high school diploma or less76% in occupations needing less than an associate's degreeThe broader definition adds occupations whose typical entry level is some college or a postsecondary certificate.
Jobs below the credential, bachelor's holders 22 to 2733% in occupations needing a high school diploma or less42% in occupations needing less than a bachelor's degreeThe broader definition counts any occupation whose BLS typical entry education is below a bachelor's degree.
Unemployment, ages 22 to 27, not enrolledAssociate's 5.0%; bachelor's 4.8%Some college, no degree 7.5%; high school 9.5%Unemployment differs less across credentials than completion does.
Appendix B

Methods and sources

About this analysis

Completion, transfer, and departure
IPEDS Outcome Measures as published in the College Scorecard institution file (November 2, 2026 update): students who entered in 2017-18, status eight years after entry. Shares are weighted by cohort size across all four entry groups. “Left, no record elsewhere” is the Outcome Measures category for students who did not receive an award and whose subsequent enrollment is unknown to the reporting college.
Work and earnings
College Scorecard field-of-study file (October 15, 2026 release): working and not-working counts, counts earning more than a high school graduate, and median earnings one year after completion, for federal aid recipients who completed in 2020-21 or 2021-22. Two benchmarks are used. The share who out-earn a high school graduate comes from Treasury counts computed against one national figure, the median earnings of high school graduates aged 25 to 34 ($35,678); the Scorecard documentation describes a single comparison figure, and our test shows the published counts match the national value, not the state values. The premium uses each state's median. Records pooled at the parent institution are counted once.
Jobs below the credential, unemployment, and adults who left
American Community Survey 2020-24 five-year microdata, people not enrolled in school, with the Bureau of Labor Statistics typical entry education for each occupation (Employment Projections 2024-34). Standard errors use the 80 replicate weights and are in the downloadable file. The ACS does not identify certificate holders, so the occupation measure covers associate's and bachelor's holders only.
Sectors
Public community and technical colleges are public institutions that mainly award certificates or associate's degrees, including Florida's state colleges. Colleges that do not report Outcome Measures, including Tennessee's colleges of applied technology and many other certificate-only schools, are left out of every stage so that completion and earnings describe the same colleges; public universities mainly award bachelor's or higher degrees. Sector follows the federal classification of the award a college mainly confers, so a few public universities that mainly award certificates or associate's degrees, such as Purdue University Global, Utah Valley University, and Weber State University, are counted with community and technical colleges. Purdue University Global is about a third of Indiana's entrants in that sector, and Utah Valley and Weber State together are about half of Utah's. Institutions that offer programs only at a distance are reported once, nationally, so that national online enrollment does not count toward the state where the institution is based.
Coverage
A state and sector is charted when at least 300 students entered and credential levels with published Scorecard work counts (at least 100 completers counted for work and 50 counted against the benchmark) account for at least 80 percent of awards. Within a level, published counts cover only the larger programs (nationally, about a third of community and technical college certificate awards and three-fifths of associate's awards), and their rates are applied to all completers at that level. The data cover federal aid recipients for earnings and all students for completion; the two stages describe different cohorts, so the journey combines rates rather than following one group of students.
Related work
State-by-state earnings premiums for graduates were published by the HEA Group in The Payoff of College Credentials (October 28, 2026), from the same Scorecard field-of-study file but a different measure: earnings four years after completion for students who completed in 2017-18 and 2018-19.
Methodology
Methodology (PDF)Definitions, cohort map, sector rules, coverage thresholds, and every check above.
How to cite
Rowe, Benazir. What Actually Happens After Students Enroll. Opportunity Data, November 17, 2026 (version 1.1, November 19, 2026). opportunitydata.org/what-actually-happens.html
Rights and reuse
© 2026 Opportunity Data. The text, charts, and derived estimates on this page, in the methodology note, and in the downloadable files are the work of Opportunity Data. You may quote the text, reproduce the charts unchanged, and use the files for analysis, including your own charts, for news reporting, research, teaching, and public policy work, with the credit “Source: Opportunity Data, opportunitydata.org.” Reselling the files, republishing them as a dataset, or building them into a commercial product requires written permission: info@opportunitydata.org. Values taken directly from federal sources (IPEDS, the College Scorecard including its NSLDS and Treasury measures, the American Community Survey, BLS Employment Projections) are public and remain free to use from their original publishers.

Version 1.1, November 19, 2026 (methodology note version 1.3); first released November 17, 2026. On November 20, 2026, Figure 1 gained a download and began showing credentials after transfer as a range; no figures changed. Version 1.1 gives credentials within eight years as a range, about 40 to 44 of 100 community and technical college starters, because the number who finish after transferring may be overstated (version 1.0 gave about 44); it adds caveats on the national benchmark, on students who leave with no record elsewhere, and on comparing sectors, and corrects how entry groups are described. One unemployment figure changed after rounding from unrounded values (bachelor's holders, 4.8%). Figures will be updated when the College Scorecard releases a new data file or IPEDS publishes the next Outcome Measures cohort; earlier versions will remain available with their release date.

Released November 2026